Black Hawk War

 

Black Hawk

Black Hawk was an old man of nearly 65 years when his world began to fall apart.

 He had bad memories of the Americans that dated back to the Revolutionary War. Colonel John Montgomery destroyed his village in June 1780 in retaliation for the tribe’s participation in the attacks on Cahokia and St. Louis.

Black Hawk was just thirteen, but the destruction of his village left an unpleasant taste in his mouth. For the rest of his life, he sided with the British.

Although not born as a chief, Black Hawk assumed a leadership role among the Sacs because of his fierceness in battle.

He made his first kill when just a boy. “I rushed furiously upon (my enemy),” bragged Black Hawk. Then, “smote him to the earth with my tomahawk.” With one flick of his scalping knife, he tore off the man’s topknot. Black Hawk rode back to his father triumphantly, shaking the bloodied scalp. When they returned home, he joined in the scalp dance for the first time.

It wasn’t the last time Black Hawk killed someone. He spent nearly ten pages recounting a host of early kills in his autobiography. Between the ages of fifteen and twenty-five, Black Hawk slew nearly thirty men, women, and children—most of them his tribe’s most hated enemy—the Osages.

Several moons after making his first kill, Black Hawk led a party of six warriors against one hundred Osages. He killed one brave, but he let another take the scalp. That success led to another war party.

This time, one hundred and eighty warriors joined Black Hawk. They traveled to the Missouri River, following it to the Osage village, but found it deserted. Most of the Sacs became discouraged and returned home. Black Hawk made two kills and returned home with the scalps, but the stench of failure clung to him. He couldn’t raise another war party until his nineteenth year.

Life along the Rock River was good and would likely have continued that way for centuries, except—the world around the Sac and Fox was changing.

Black Hawk's first kill

Thomas Jefferson purchased Louisiana from France in 1803. The following year, he sent two expeditions to explore the new lands. Meriwether Lewis, William Clark, and their Corps of Discovery set off from St. Louis in 1804. They traversed the continent over the next two years, eventually reaching Fort Clatsop on the Pacific Coast.

The Sacs saw their first American since the revolution in 1805 when Zebulon Pike stopped at Saukenuk. Jefferson charged Pike with finding the source of the Mississippi. Along the way, he met with representatives of the Indian nations.

Pike presented the Sacs with an American flag. “He then requested us to pull down our British flags,” said Black Hawk, “and give him our British medals.” Black Hawk refused, saying, “We wished to have two fathers.”

Overall, Pike made a good impression on the Sac. “He was a good man and a great brave,” said Black Hawk. Unknown to Black Hawk, Pike noted in his journal that “this would be a good place for a garrison.”

Five Sac chiefs signed a treaty in St. Louis about the same time. They sold nearly fifty million acres of land without the permission of the tribe. Article 7 of the treaty became one of the chief causes of the Black Hawk War. It stated, “As long as the lands which are now ceded to the United States remain their property, the Indians belonging to the said tribes shall enjoy the privilege of living or hunting upon them.”

Black Hawk's meeting with Zebulon Pike

There would have been no problem if the Sacs had been forced to leave their lands immediately, but they continued to occupy the area for nearly thirty years as if nothing had transpired. Over time, Black Hawk’s mind grew fuzzy. He insisted his people never sold the land his village sat on.

Black Hawk explained the Indian’s view of the treaty in his autobiography.

A Sac warrior killed an American and was imprisoned in St. Louis. The tribe selected five elders to secure his release. The Indian custom was to pay the dead person’s relatives to make things even. They figured it worked the same way with the whites.

The Sac delegation met with William Henry Harrison in St. Louis. “He wanted land,” said Black Hawk, “and they agreed to give him some on the west side of the Mississippi and some on the Illinois side opposite the Jeffreon.” Afterward, the soldiers let their friend out of prison. He “ran a short distance and was shot dead!”

The chiefs could not remember much more. “They had been drunk for the greater part of the time they were in St. Louis.”

Confusion over the terms of the treaty sparked the Black Hawk War.

But that’s nearly thirty years in the future. Britain and America were at war again in 1812, and both countries wanted the Indians on their side. Or if they would not fight, to remain neutral.

The War of 1812 became another flashpoint for the Sac. Black Hawk remained undecided whether to fight or stay neutral. “I had not discovered one good trait in the character of the Americans,” said Black Hawk. “They made fair promises but never fulfilled them. Whilst the British made but few—but we could always rely upon their word.”

Black Hawk said the Americans forced his people to join the British. Several Sac chiefs visited Washington before the war. They received a promise from the trader at Fort Madison that he would supply them with credit for the provisions necessary for their winter hunt. The traders were pleasant enough when they arrived at the fort but refused to give them credit.

The following day, Black Hawk received word that Edward Lagoterie, a British trader, was waiting for him at Saukenuk with two canoe loads of supplies.

When Black Hawk reached his village, Lagoterie told him that Robert Dickson, the Indian agent at Prairie du Chien, wanted the Sacs to join him at Green Bay. He had twelve more boats filled with guns, ammunition, and other supplies.

Black Hawk raised a band of 200 warriors and set off for Green Bay. After a few months, he tired of the British way of fighting and returned to his village.

Black Hawk mocked how foolishly the whites fought. “Instead of stealing upon each other and taking every advantage to kill the enemy and save their own people, they march out in open daylight and fight. Regardless of the number of warriors, they may lose.”

Black Hawk met with Lieutenant John Campbell of the 1st US Regiment of Infantry on July 18, 1814. Campbell reported that the Indians were friendly.

He met a party of Sac warriors carrying a white flag just below the Rock River Rapids. They invited him to Saukenuk for a council, so he traveled about four miles upstream to their village to meet with them.

There were maybe 150 warriors, plus their women and children. One chief (most likely Black Hawk) asked if he had presents for them. Campbell replied he did if they went to war against the Peaus as promised. The chief said he’d made no such promise to his white father. “His father was drunk if he said so.” However, the chief agreed to attack the Peaus if Campbell supplied them with the necessary weapons.

Campbell stayed at Rock River for three days, from July 28 to 31, then set off for Prairie du Chien. The soldiers didn’t travel more than six miles before hurricane-force winds grounded their boats.

Battle of Campbell's Island

The area they stopped at was covered in high grass, and hazel and willow bushes lined the shore for some distance. They weren’t there for more than a half-hour before the Indians attacked. Both sentinels Campbell posted died in the first fire.

The soldiers tried to get the boats off the shore, but the wind was too strong. Campbell ordered the men to defend themselves to the “last extremity,” and they did. The fighting lasted nearly two and a half hours.

The wind was blowing so hard that it took Lieutenant Elias Rector and Ensign Jonathan Riggs nearly an hour to get their boats close enough to assist. By that time, Campbell’s boat was a flaming hulk. Rector maneuvered his boat alongside Campbell’s and evacuated the survivors.

Black Hawk explained that a British party had come down the Rock River the previous night. They said that the British had taken Fort Shelby, opposite Prairie du Chien, and asked him to “join them again in the war.”

The next day, the Sac and Fox attacked Campbell’s party with 500 warriors. “If we had known the day before,” laughed Black Hawk, “we could easily have taken them all, as the war chief used no precautions.”

Black Hawk’s men scalped five dead regulars and danced over the scalps to celebrate their victory at the Battle of Campbell’s Island.

The Americans took another drubbing at the Battle of Credit Island in August 1814. 

William Clark, governor of the Missouri Territory, intended to even the score with the Sac and Fox for the fall of Fort Shelby and the attack on Lieutenant Campbell. He ordered Zachary Taylor to destroy the Sac and Fox villages on the Rock and Mississippi Rivers. Taylor set off from Cape au Gris, Missouri, on August 23, with 334 men loaded in eight large, fortified keelboats. They reached Rock River on the evening of September 5.

A storm blew the expedition’s boats ashore on Credit Island. The following day, a large party of Sac and Fox warriors was spotted moving toward the island. Taylor formed his troops for battle on the Iowa shore. Captain Rector landed his boat on Credit Island and set up his artillery.

Taylor’s boats were no match for the British artillery. He was forced to order his boats downstream. Taylor reported that he hoped to draw the Indians into a council. “I was in hopes to draw them some distance from their towns towards the rapids,” explained Taylor, “run down in the night and destroy them before they could return to their defenses.”

Unfortunately, it didn’t work out that way. The wind shifted “and blew a perfect hurricane.” The troops made landfall on a small island in the middle of the river. Around 4 p.m., they noticed Indians along the banks of both shores and more crossing over in canoes.

Zachary Taylor in the Battle of Credit Island

No shots were fired that night. The Indians shot and killed a corporal standing guard on Captain Samuel Whiteside’s boat the next day.

It soon became apparent that Taylor didn’t have the manpower or weapons to overpower the Indians. Nor could he destroy their villages and burn their corn, so he decided to drop down the river and construct a fort at the entrance of the Des Moines River.

British Lieutenant Duncan Graham reported that the Americans built a fort at the entrance of the Des Moines River. “The fort is about fifty yards square,” said Graham, “and is picketed in with very large oak pickets about twelve feet high and is situated on a high hill. They have cleared all the trees and brush from the back part of their fort to the distance of a musket shot, but in the front to the waterside, they have left a thick wood standing, I suppose to cover their going for water.” He noted a small hill, somewhat higher than the fort, about seven or eight hundred yards distant.

Taylor blamed failing to complete his mission on the British artillery. “I conceive it would have been madness in me, as well as a direct violation of my orders,” wrote Taylor, “to have risked the detachment without a prospect of success.”

Black Hawk felt cheated.

“I was prepared to meet them,” he said, “but was soon sadly disappointed—the boats had started down the river.” In the end, the Battle of Credit Island was a minor skirmish.

Black Hawk signed his first treaty at St. Louis in 1816. Little did he know that he had agreed to abide by the Treaty of 1804. His signature gave away his village on Rock River. Shortly after that, American soldiers began constructing Fort Armstrong at Rock Island.

“We did not object to their building the fort on the island,” said Black Hawk, “but we were very sorry, as this was the best island on the Mississippi. A good spirit had care of it, who lived in a cave in the rocks immediately under the place where the fort now stands.” But since the coming of the soldiers, the spirit had left.

In the same year, George Davenport became the post sutler at Fort Armstrong. Two years later, Antoine Le Claire came to the island as the Indian interpreter. 

Squatters began encroaching on Black Hawk’s village during the summer of 1823 while the Indians were away on their winter hunt.

The Treaty of 1804 guaranteed the Sac and Fox the use of their lands so long as they remained un-surveyed and not sold to individuals. The frontier was still fifty miles to the east, and the country between had not yet been surveyed or explored. The squatters had no legal right to be on this land. By law, the government should have protected the Indians, but the authorities tended to look the other way.

The Sacs were willing to live with the settlers. What bothered them was the newcomers destroying their homes and plowing up their cornfields. Saukenuk was their birthplace. It contained the main cemetery of their tribe.

The squatters fenced in the Indian cornfields and whipped and beat the squaws and children who got in their way. They burned the Indian lodges and dug up their cornfields. Black Hawk complained to the authorities at Fort Armstrong, but nothing happened. Each year, the problem worsened. When they returned from their winter hunt, the Sacs found their homes destroyed, their fields fenced in and plowed up by the whites.

It was no surprise that the Sacs pushed back. The actual surprise was they didn’t react more violently sooner. The kindling was there as early as 1823.

Black Hawk asked his rival, Chief Keokuk, to intercede. Maybe the whites would take some other lands—even their lead mines further north by Dubuque and Galena. He was willing to do whatever it took “to be peaceably permitted to keep the small point of land on which our village was situated.”

Keokuk and Thomas Forsyth, the Indian agent at Fort Armstrong, offered no help. They advised Black Hawk to make a peaceful retreat across the Mississippi. Keokuk had already moved his Peace Faction to the Iowa River. Chief Wapello moved his band near the Muscatine Slough. Only Black Hawk remained, reluctant to leave his ancestral home. He claimed the Sac and Fox chiefs who signed the treaty of 1804 never agreed to give away the land their village was on.

“I questioned Quashquame about the sale of the lands,” said Black Hawk. “He assured me that he had never consented to the sale of our village.” Black Hawk’s trusted advisors said the government did not legally own his village’s site if this was true, so they told him to hold fast to his town. The United States would not dare to remove him by force.

“I heard that there was a great chief on the Wabash and sent a party to get his advice.” That chief said the same thing, so Black Hawk asked the British Father at Malden. “He gave the same reply that the chief on the Wabash had given. This assured me that I was right and determined me to hold out, as I had promised our people.”

That advice was the beginning of the end for the Sac and Fox Nation.

By 1831, the state of Illinois had had enough of arguing with Indians. They warned Black Hawk that if he crossed the Mississippi River and returned to his village at Saukenuk, they would consider it an act of aggression.

For a few tense moments, it appeared war was imminent. Illinois Governor John Reynolds called out 1,600 members of the militia. Ten companies of regulars commanded by General Edmund P. Gaines reinforced them.

In June, Gaines gathered the tribes at Rock Island, hoping to persuade the Sacs to move peaceably. Instead, Black Hawk and his warriors made things worse. They arrived at the council singing a war song, armed with lances, spears, clubs, and bows.

When Black Hawk refused to budge, Gaines rose to his full height and bellowed, “Who is Black Hawk?”

When he was sure that nothing he said would work, Gaines stopped mincing words and laid it on the line. “My business is to remove you. Peacefully if I can. Forcibly if I must. I will now give you two days to remove. If you do not cross the Mississippi within that time, I will adopt measures to force you away.”

Black Hawk said he could have killed Gaines right then. He was probably right. An observer noted that the Sacs “came into the council house yesterday with spears, hatchets, and bows strung. I have no doubt...there was more danger than most were aware of. Our troops were near a quarter mile off, and there were about ten for one of us.”

Black Hawk discarded the idea of killing Gaines as foolish. He told the general, “He would not fight, and he would not leave.” If the soldiers “came to drive him off, he would sit down in his wigwam, and they could do what they pleased with him. He would do nothing.”

After seeing the number of troops lined up against him, Black Hawk reconsidered. He slipped away overnight rather than fight. The following week, Black Hawk returned to Fort Armstrong, where he signed a peace treaty with Governor John Reynolds and General Gaines. He agreed to abide by the previous treaties and not cross the river into Illinois.

Intertribal squabbles triggered another treaty violation the next month. For years, American policy had focused on preventing intertribal warfare—forbidding attacks on neighboring tribes.

A marauding band of Menominee and Sioux disregarded the treaty and killed several members of Black Hawk’s band. A party of Sac warriors took revenge the following year and massacred twenty-five Menominee camped on the island opposite Fort Crawford at Prairie du Chien on July 31, 1831.

The Menominee complained to General Joseph Street, the Indian agent at Prairie du Chien. He demanded the Sacs turn the guilty men over for trial. Black Hawk refused. Why should he? The members of the party that killed his warriors were never punished. Why should his warriors be punished?

Getting entangled in a war with the United States was the last thing on Black Hawk’s mind. He crossed the Mississippi in the spring of 1832 with only one goal—to plant corn to feed his starving band.

“If the Americans came and told them to move,” said Neapope, “we should have shaken hands and immediately have moved peaceably.”

By coincidence, General Henry Atkinson arrived at Fort Armstrong just days after the Sacs crossed into Illinois. He was there to apprehend the Sacs responsible for the Menominee massacre the previous year, but turned his attention to the developing crisis.

Atkinson sent a message to the Sacs, ordering them to cross the river or face the consequences. Black Hawk replied that “his heart was bad. He was determined not to head back.”

Illinois Governor John Reynolds overreacted and panicked settlers when he proclaimed that the Indians had invaded Illinois.

News of the supposed invasion brought out every backwoods yokel and Indian hater in the territory. Many of them had a grudge to settle. Others were eager to get their hands on the Sac lands along the Mississippi and Rock Rivers—even if it meant killing every member of the Sac and Fox tribes.

What followed was a mix-up of frontier murder, madness, and mayhem. Illinois Governor John Reynolds called out the militia and raised thousands of volunteers. General Winfield Scott marched his regulars to Fort Armstrong at Rock Island. Zachary Taylor led a group of dragoons in the fighting. 

The first engagement proved a comedy of errors. Major Isaiah Stillman bivouacked his troops in a clump of open timber three miles southwest of the mouth of Sycamore Creek. His men scouted the area, trying to find Black Hawk’s warriors.

Black Hawk realized he didn’t stand a chance, so when he learned Stillman’s troops were nearby, he sent three braves to make peace. They walked towards the soldiers carrying a white flag of truce. Five other braves followed on horseback at a safe distance. Their job was to hang back and keep Black Hawk informed of what transpired.

A group of soldiers spotted the five watchers and chased after them.

Black Hawk couldn’t believe what he saw. First, the soldiers disregarded his white flag and shot down all three of his flag bearers. Then they attacked his watchers, slaying two of them.

 He gave up all thoughts of making peace. Black Hawk tore up his flag of truce and encouraged his men to attack the soldiers despite the Sacs being outnumbered and facing almost certain death.

Black Hawk ordered his warriors to hide in a clump of bushes. The militia stopped a short distance from them. “I gave another yell and ordered my brave warriors to charge upon them,” said Black Hawk, “expecting that we should all be killed. Every man rushed and charged, and the enemy retreated.”

Black Hawk could not believe his good fortune. He expected his entire party would be killed. Instead, his forty warriors whipped several hundred.

Battle of Stillman's Run

What should have been a peaceful end to the Black Hawk War turned into a full-fledged tragedy for whites and Indians alike. Black Hawk was “forced into war, with about five hundred warriors, to contend against three or four thousand.”

Newspaper accounts called the Sac depredations after the Battle of Stillman’s Run the worst ever recorded. The dead militiamen’s “heads and limbs were severed from their bodies.” The body parts littered the ground, tossed to and fro in “wanton and savage triumph.”

The Nile’s Weekly Register provided a more vivid account. “The dead that were found were cut and mangled most shocking and indecent; their hearts cut out, heads off, and every other spot indignity practiced upon their person.”

The soldier’s bodies were treated miserably, but the Indian dead didn’t fare any better. Captain J. W. Stephenson fought a bloody battle near Apple River on June 19. The Indians stole ten horses outside the stockade at Galena the previous night. 

The following day, Stephenson chased them into the woods. The thickets were so dense that his men were forced to dismount and charge the warriors on foot. The soldiers were so close their guns were useless. Stephenson reported, “We killed five or six of the damned scoundrels and lost three of our own men.” His men charged the Indian camp four times. They fought “with knives, spears, tomahawks, clubs, guns, and bayonets.”

When the soldiers rode into Galena, they waved two scalps in the air, whooping and hollering as they went. 

Black Hawk displayed his genius for war after the fighting at Sycamore Creek. He divided his force into several smaller war parties, keeping the larger band of 200 for himself. Several smaller bands of Winnebago joined him, and 100 Pottawatomie were commanded by the British agent, Mike Girty.

Black Hawk never engaged his full force or attacked military strongholds. Instead, small bands of warriors terrorized the poorly defended settlements and lone travelers.

The Sacs spent most of late May and June in the Four Lakes region, near present-day Madison, Wisconsin. The swamps and marshes made it easy to hide but hard to find food, so the Sacs resorted to eating roots and bark.

The army spent most of its time following up on guerrilla raids. A band of Menominee and Sac warriors led by Mike Girty slaughtered fifteen men, women, and children at the Davis farm on Indian Creek on May 22. Sylvia and Rachel Hall were taken prisoner and later ransomed for $2,000 to White Crow, a Winnebago chief. He turned them over to Henry Gratiot, sub-agent for the Winnebago at Blue Mounds, on June 3.

Indian Creek massacre

Black Hawk led an attack on the Apple River Fort, fourteen miles east of Galena, Illinois, on June 24. The next day, he attacked the stockade at Kellogg’s Grove. Fifteen Sacs and five whites died in the fighting.

By mid-July, Black Hawk decided it was time to move or die, so he led his followers toward the Wisconsin River. He could make it to the Mississippi and cross into safety if luck was with him.

Colonel Henry Dodge’s mounted rangers caught up with the Sac near Wisconsin Heights on July 21.

For the Sac, the battle of Wisconsin Heights served more as a holding action. Black Hawk’s 120 warriors fought off nearly 700 troops led by Colonel Dodge and General James Henry. Simultaneously, the women and children attempted to cross the Wisconsin River in makeshift canoes and rafts.

Black Hawk sat on his white horse atop a small hill, directing his warriors. His men hid along the hilltops. As the militia approached the riverbanks, they peppered the riverbank with rifle fire.

The Sacs made several charges but could not break through the lines. Dodge’s volunteers kept their cool. When the Sac came within thirty feet, the militia let out a blood-curdling war cry and opened fire.

Black Hawk withdrew his men after he was sure the women and children had escaped. Sixty-seven warriors lay dead along the riverbank.

Black Hawk rallying his warriors at Battle of Wisconsin Heights

“I would not have fought,” recalled Black Hawk, “but to gain time for my women and children to cross.”

Colonel Dodge wrote General Atkinson the day after the battle: “We met the enemy yesterday. Our loss was one man killed and eight wounded... We must have killed forty of them.”

His only worry was that the remaining Sacs might escape by water. “If you could place a field piece immediately on the Wisconsin that would command the river, you might prevent their escape,” he told Atkinson.

The army crossed the Wisconsin River in close pursuit of the Sac. The Indians reached the intersection of the Bad Axe and Mississippi Rivers on August 1.

Black Hawk stepped onto the bank, holding a white flag as the steamboat Warrior neared the shore. He called Captain Throckmorton in Winnebago and asked him to send a boat ashore so the Sacs could give themselves up. A Winnebago told Throckmorton that Black Hawk wished to surrender, but the captain was suspicious.

The Warrior fired three rounds of canister. Then, the troops opened fire with their muskets. Twenty-three members of the British Band died during the hour-long fight. One man on the Warrior was injured.

After the Warrior pulled away, Black Hawk tried to move his followers north to the Winnebago villages of Big Canoe and Winneshiek. Very few of them listened. Instead, they continued toward the Mississippi and what they considered safety. Black Hawk left his followers there and took his family north to the Winnebago village at Prairie La Crosse.

When the last battle occurred the next day, none of the three primary leaders were present. White Cloud, Neapope, and Black Hawk had sought shelter elsewhere.

“The Indians fought desperately from tree to tree,” reported Stevens, “falling back step by step until the river was reached when, by a bayonet charge, they were driven into the river. Some tried to swim. Others took shelter in a willow island.”

By then, it was as good as over.

The regulars moved up and opened fire on the Indians—killing many women and children along with the warriors. The troops regretted it, said Stevens, but the squaws were dressed as men and with them, so it could not be helped.

“Some of the [Sacs] succeeded in swimming to the west bank,” wrote historian Reuben Gold Thwaites. “Many were drowned on the way or coolly picked off by sharpshooters. They “treated them all as though they were rats instead of human beings.”

My people “tried to give themselves up,” said Black Hawk. “The whites paid no attention to their entreaties—but commenced slaughtering them. Our braves, finding that the enemy paid no regard to age or sex and seeing that they were murdering helpless women and little children, determined to fight until they were killed.

The massacre at Bad Axe

“As many women as could commenced swimming the Mississippi, with their children on their backs. A number of them were drowned, and some shot before they could reach the opposite shore.”

Historians estimate the British Band numbered 500 when they reached Bad Axe. Roughly 150 men, women, and children died in the fighting. Another 100, maybe more, drowned trying to cross the Mississippi, so the soldiers effectively killed half the remaining members of the British Band. Patrick Jung determined that 520 of Black Hawk’s party perished between April and August 1832.

On September 3, 1832, a band of Winnebago turned Black Hawk, Neapope, and the Prophet over to Indian agent Joseph Street in Prairie du Chien. He transferred custody of them to Colonel Zachary Taylor at Fort Crawford.

When the war ended, Black Hawk, his two sons, the Winnebago Prophet, and five other principal members of the tribe were held prisoner at Jefferson Barracks, St. Louis.

After spending several months in prison, the Indian Department sent Black Hawk on a whirlwind tour of the East Coast. He visited Washington, Philadelphia, Baltimore, and several other cities along the way.

Black Hawk's tour of the East Coast

He traveled by steamboat, stagecoach, and the newly built railroads. In New York City, Black Hawk watched a balloon ascension at Castle Garden.

When Black Hawk met Andrew Jackson in Baltimore, the president gave him some fatherly advice. “Our young men are as numerous as the leaves in the woods. What can you do against us? You may kill a few women and children, but such a force would be soon sent against you as would destroy your whole tribe.

“Let the red man hunt and take care of their families, but I hope they will not again rise their hands against their white brethren.

“We do not wish to ruin you. We desire your prosperity and improvement. But if you again plunge your knives into the breasts of our people, I shall send a force, which will severely punish you for all your cruelties.”

Black Hawk agreed he had misbehaved and promised to be peaceful from then on. Later, in Washington, he shook hands with President Jackson, telling him, “You are one man. I am another.” It was a poignant reminder; they were both people. While their circumstances were different, neither man was better than the other.

After the war ended, public sentiment quickly shifted to the Indians. John Barton Patterson, editor of the Galenian during the Black Hawk War, did not think Black Hawk was the bloodthirsty savage the government made him out to be.

Black Hawk “repeatedly advised non-resistance,” said Patterson. He “did not attribute the war to the border white people, but to far different causes.” Especially “[Keokuk, and his peace party], deceptive treaties, and a firm belief that [the] government was trespassing upon his rights.”

It’s an entirely different view of the conflict, written by someone intimately involved in the Black Hawk War. Patterson said that during the war, he “advocated the cause of the white settlers.” Afterward, he “became satisfied of the sincerity of [Black Hawk’s] motives.”

Others blamed the Indian traders. They had more to gain from an Indian war than anyone else. The tribes owed them large sums they could never repay. A quick war could change all that.

An 1893 article in the Burlington Hawk-Eye suggested that George Davenport, the Indian trader at Fort Armstrong, caused the war. “The Sac chief had become indebted to Davenport and was unable to pay,” said the paper. So Davenport “hit upon the plan of having Black Hawk invade his old lands in Illinois. Anticipating that a short conflict would ensue, followed by a treaty, by which Davenport hoped to get from Uncle Sam the balance due him by Black Hawk.”

Historian Jacob Van Der Zee agreed with that assessment. He said, “In 1830, a trader asserted that the Sacs and Foxes wished to sell all lands bordering on the Mississippi provided the government would pay the Indian debts to Messrs. Farnham and Davenport.”

Whoever was at fault, Black Hawk took the president’s advice. He lived a peaceful life. He attended many old-time settler’s celebrations and took part in several Fourth of July parades towards the end of his days.

 Before you go ...

If you’ve ever caught yourself saying, “I remember that,” you’re in the right place.

I dig up stories about Old West lawmen, outlaws, gunfighters, robberies, murders, forgotten towns, and all the strange, fascinating pieces of history that somehow slipped through the cracks. No clickbait. No fluff. Just authentic stories and actual history.

If you enjoy what you read and would like to help keep the lights on, consider buying me a Big Gulp.

Every little bit helps pay for books, newspaper archives, research trips, and the countless hours spent tracking down stories most people forgot decades ago.

Buy Me a Big Gulp / NickVulich.com

If the Old West is your thing, you may enjoy these books...

Shot All To Hell

Shot All To Pieces

No comments:

Post a Comment