Tecumseh And The Prophet

 

Tecumseh (based on a line drawing by Benjamin J. Lossing)

Forty years after Pontiac’s failed confederacy, two new leaders emerged among the Shawnee—Tecumseh and his brother, Tenskwatawa.

The brothers were polar opposites. Tecumseh stood almost six feet tall, had a muscular build, and had a forceful personality. Tenskwatawa was short and stout—a disfigured ex-alcoholic, often described as “ugly,” who wore an eyepatch to cover a self-inflicted wound. As a child, he shot his eye out with a bow.

Historians have long debated which brother led the rebellion—Tecumseh or Tenskwatawa. Stephen Ruddell, an intimate friend of Tecumseh, who lived amongst the Shawnee for nearly twenty years, felt it was Tenskwatawa. “Tecumseh was the tool of the prophet,” he said, which was hard for him to understand because “Tecumseh was the much smarter man in every respect.”

Historian Peter Cozzens suggested that the brother’s accomplishments were intertwined. “Without Tenskwatawa,” he said, “there would have been no Tecumseh.” Benjamin Drake, an early biographer of Tecumseh, said, “While the prophet was normally head of the party, and undoubtedly exercised much influence by means of his supernatural power, he was but an agent—controlled and directed by a master spirit.”

Some of the confusion may have been by design. Tecumseh stayed in the background and remained off the whites’ radar until just before the War of 1812. The British and Americans knew of him, but Tenskwatawa was considered the leader and main instigator of the Indian troubles in the Northwest—not Tecumseh.

Tecumseh’s early battles

The Shawnee world was in a state of flux at Tecumseh’s birth. The tribe had recently moved to Piqua, near present-day Springfield, Ohio, where they planted crops and built a thriving village along the Mad River. A crude log fort stood along the riverbanks with walls twenty feet high.

That world fell apart when Tecumseh turned twelve. George Rogers Clark and his Kentuckians destroyed the Shawnee towns in May 1780. They burned old Chillicothe. From there, they moved on to Piqua.

George Rogers Clark's Ketuckians burned Piqua when Tecuseh was just a boy

The Kentuckians burned the native huts as they advanced. Dead and dying warriors lay all around them. Then finally, the Shawnee cut and ran into the forests. The Americans tore up the Shawnee cornfields, burned their homes, and killed everyone in sight.

The remaining Shawnee moved their village to a spot on the Great Miami River and named it Piqua after the old town. If anything, the attacks led to a festering hatred of Americans in Tecumseh’s heart.

Tradition has it that Tecumseh joined a war party that attacked some Kentuckians on the Mad River in his early teens. Some chiefs say he panicked and ran. If so, that was the last time.

Anthony Wayne’s troops attacked the Native Americans near the Rapids of the Miami on August 20, 1794. Tecumseh’s gun misfired, and he was forced to retreat. He borrowed a fowling piece from another group of warriors and led a charge. Once again, they were driven back.

He rallied his warriors at another point and made a stand in the thickets. Tecumseh’s braves discharged their muskets, then fell back below the Rapids of the Miami.

The Americans won the day, but Tecumseh earned new honors for his bravery.

In the Treaty of Greenville, concluded on August 3, 1795, the assembled tribes agreed to live peaceably and stop intertribal fighting. They ceded southern and eastern Ohio, most of southern Indiana, and 150,000 acres near the Falls of the Ohio. In return, they received a $9,500 annuity.

Ninety-nine chiefs signed the treaty. Tecumseh spent the remainder of his life fighting its provisions. He maintained that the Ohio River was the correct boundary between Native Americans and whites.

Tecumseh began gathering his band in 1795

His brother, Lalawethika, became a medicine man at about the same time. After the death of Penagashega (the old medicine man) in 1805, he changed his name to Tenskwatawa—the Open Door.

One day, while smoking his pipe, Tenskwatawa fell over as if dead. Relatives washed his body and prepared him for burial. The next day, while they dug his grave, Tenskwatawa came to and shared his astounding vision.

Tenskwatawa raises his arms in thros of a vision

He said he traveled high into the clouds. “The first place he came to was the dwelling of the devil.” It was filled with drunkards spewing flames from their mouths. Seeing that made him stop drinking.

The Great Spirit told him that Indian women should not intermarry with the whites. The tribes should renounce all the white man’s goods, except guns and ammunition. Tenskwatawa called on everyone to return to the simple lifestyle before the whites came.

In April 1806, William Henry Harrison, governor of the Indiana Territory, devised what he thought was a foolproof plan to expose the prophet as a fraud. “If he is really a prophet,” Harrison told the Shawnee, “ask him to cause the sun to stand still—the moon to alter its course—the rivers cease to flow—or the dead to rise from their graves. If he does these things, you may then believe that he has been sent from God.”

Tenskwatawa remained quiet until June. Then, on June 16, the day of the solar eclipse, Tenskwatawa made a big show in front of his followers.

Tenskwatawa commans the sun to vanish, and stay hidden

He ordered the sun to disappear and then to reappear. Imagine their surprise when it happened—just as he commanded. William Henry Harrison had unknowingly enhanced the prophet’s reputation.

Trouble at Greenville

In 1807, an Indian trader told reporters that the prophet “spoke very disrespectfully of the people of the United States, saying he could turn them over as easy as a basin of water. Then, he rose, discharged wind loudly [farted], clapped his hand to his backside, and exclaimed he cared no more for them than that.”

The trader was “sure something dangerous was brewing.” Why else would all those warriors be trekking to the prophet’s village at Greenville with rifles in their hands?

Tenskwatawa denied making the statement. He told Stephen Ruddell the reports were “false and unfounded slander.” His enemies often put words in his mouth to make him look bad. He had made no agreements with the British, nor did he plan to fight the Americans. Ruddell left the meeting confident the prophet had no “hostile intentions” towards the United States.

William Wells, the American Indian agent, agreed. “The Indians continue to flock to Greenville in large numbers,” he said, “but I cannot see any danger to be apprehended from them. They appear religiously mad. Tell the people not to be alarmed. There is no danger as yet.”

Indian interpreter John Conner met with the prophet in July 1808 to retrieve some stolen horses. Tenskwatawa assured him that “he had not the smallest idea of doing any harm.” His only intention was to “lead the Indians out of darkness and show them the light.”

The tribesmen at Prophetstown were starving when Conner met them. Tenskwatawa planned to visit Governor Harrison at Vincennes to ask for provisions. His people were trying to raise corn but would not have enough to live on until the following year. The prophet’s followers posed no threat to anyone in their present condition.

That should have ended Harrison’s worries, but in the spring of 1809, some of the friendly tribes warned Harrison that Tecumseh planned to massacre the inhabitants of Vincennes. Harrison grew paranoid and became convinced that war was imminent.

He sent a message to the prophet, reassuring him that he was not his enemy. Still, he believed Tenskwatawa was “an enemy of the Seventeen Fires.” Even though Tenskwatawa had done much to incite the tribes, “little harm” had been done yet. What harm that was done could easily be repaired, said Harrison.

Then, he threw down a challenge.

“The chain of friendship which united the whites with the Indians may be renewed and be as strong as ever. A great deal of that work depends on you—the destiny of those who are under you depends on the choices you make of the two roads which are before you. The one is open and pleasant and leads to peace... the other is narrow and crooked and leads to misery and ruin.”

Harrison reminded the prophet that he had no chance in a war with the Americans. “Our blue coats are more numerous than you can count. Our hunters are like the leaves of the forest or the grains of sand on the Wabash.” The British would be no help to them. “They are not able to protect themselves.”

Later that year, more rumors surfaced that the tribes intended to exterminate the residents of Vincennes. Harrison did not think it was probable then because the prophet had only one hundred warriors in his village. Still, he decided it was best to prepare.

Harrison raised two volunteer militia companies and ordered them to occupy Fort Knox—a post two miles from Vincennes.

The paranoia continued to build over the next year, despite the lack of hostilities. In April 1810, several traders told Harrison the British were stirring up trouble among the Indians—providing the tribes with powder and balls. As a result, the tribes refused to buy from American traders—saying they got it elsewhere for free.

An Iowa Indian reported a British agent visiting the Prophet two years back. He instructed him to continue uniting the tribes but not strike until the British gave the signal. The prophet solicited him and other tribes along the Mississippi to join his confederacy.

The prophet told them that even though the Americans had not invaded their territory yet, they would. It was the duty of all tribes who had not lost their lands yet to help those who had. The Great Spirit would “utterly destroy” them if they refused.

Tecumseh’s Indian confederacy experienced a bumpy ride during its first few years. Delegations from many tribes came to investigate but left just as quickly. The area around Greenville and on the Wabash could not support so many people. The prophet promised his followers that food would be plentiful. Instead, they starved or were forced to beg for food from the soldiers at Vincennes.

The pan-Indian movement might have disappeared on its own—then and there—if William Henry Harrison hadn’t engineered the Fort Wayne Treaty in September 1809. It gave Tecumseh and Tenskwatawa the ammunition they needed to grow their confederacy.

The land dispute

The Fort Wayne Treaty snatched nearly three million acres in Illinois and Indiana from the tribes. The Miami (the rightful owners) opposed the treaty for several reasons. First, under the Treaty of Greenville signed in 1795, they were guaranteed the use of the lands around the Wabash. Second, they demanded that Harrison pay them a fair price per acre rather than purchasing the land as one large parcel. Finally, they objected that the tract’s primary residents were the Weas, and they did not take part in the negotiations. Harrison steamrolled over their objections and purchased the land for roughly two cents an acre when the going rate was $2.00.

The move was classic William Henry Harrison. In Mr. Jefferson’s Hammer, Robert M. Owens said Harrison’s favorite negotiating tactic was including tribes with “little claim to an area.” They were more likely to sell because they had no stake in the game. That’s what Harrison did at Fort Wayne. He negotiated the treaty with the Delaware, Potawatomi, and just one Miami band.

Tecumseh was away when the Fort Wayne Treaty was made. He threatened to kill all the chiefs involved when he learned about it.

Harrison assured Tecumseh that the treaty would not affect his claims to the ceded lands. “If they were found to be valid, the land would be given up or ample compensation made for it.”

The show down at Vincennes

William Henry Harrison called a council at Vincennes in August 1810 to address Tecumseh’s concerns. The chief arrived with 175 warriors armed with war clubs, tomahawks, bows, and arrows.

Tecumseh's warriors raised their weapons as if to attack Harrison at Vincennes

“The Great Spirit gave this great island (America) to his red children,” said Tecumseh. “He placed the whites on the other side of the big water. They were not content with their own but came to take ours.”

Tecumseh insisted the Great Spirit gave the lands “as common property to all the Indians.” The land “could not, nor should not be sold without the consent of all. All the tribes upon the continent formed but one nation.”

He acknowledged he had threatened to kill all the chiefs who signed the Fort Wayne treaty. He would “not permit the village chiefs in the future to manage their affairs, but to place the power with which they had been heretofore invested in the hands of the war chiefs.”

Harrison replied that the Indians are “not one nation.” They do not “have a common property in the lands.” If it had been the Great Spirits’ intention, “he would not have put different tongues in their heads, but to have taught them all to speak the same language.” Harrison was confident the president supported separate tribal ownership of the Indian lands and would fight for it.

Tecumseh hoped that wasn’t so, but the president would not be injured if it came to war. “He may sit in his town and drink his wine,” said Tecumseh, “while you and I will have to fight it out.”

The warriors sprang to their feet, war clubs in hand. Harrison jumped up and pulled his sword. His assistant, Captain Floyd, drew a dirk, and for a moment, violence seemed imminent. Then just as quickly, the native delegation left.

Tecumseh returned the next day and apologized for his rudeness. However, he clarified that no more land would be sold.

“The only way to stop this evil is for all the red men to unite in claiming a common and equal right in the land...it never was divided but belongs to all. No tribe has a right to sell, even to each other, much less to strangers who will take all and demand no less.

“The white people have no right to take the land from the Indians, who had it first. It is theirs. They may sell it, but all must join. Any sale not made by all is no good.”

He told Harrison: “If the president would give up the lands purchased and agree never to make another treaty without the consent of all the tribes; he would be their faithful ally and assist them in the war he knew was about to take place with England. He preferred being the ally of the Seventeen Fires,” but—it depended upon the Americans’ actions.

The wheels in Harrison’s mind began to turn as soon as the council broke up. He wrote the Secretary of War that Tecumseh’s “absence affords a most favorable opportunity for breaking up his confederacy.”

As for the prophet, he was “deficient in judgment and talents.” It would be easy to destroy him while Tecumseh is away.

Harrison wrote the Secretary of War, expressing his growing concerns over the Native American confederacy. “There can be no doubt of his [Tecumseh’s] intention to excite the southern Indians to war against us. The implicit obedience and respect which the tribes pay him are really astonishing. More than any other circumstance [they] bespeak him one of those uncommon geniuses which spring up occasionally to produce revolutions and overturn the existing order of things.”

He noted that Tecumseh was a burst of energy—always on the move. One moment he was on the Wabash. Next, he was on the shores of Lake Michigan or the banks of the Mississippi.

Tecumseh builds his alliance

After the council at Vincennes, Tecumseh traveled west on a recruiting mission. He visited the tribes in Illinois, Wisconsin, and the western Shawnee living in Missouri. Still, Tecumseh came home empty-handed. His only convert was Shabbona, an Ottawa chief living in northern Illinois. Shabbona promised to visit Prophetstown in the spring.

In July 1811, Tecumseh assured Harrison that all the talk about hostilities was unfounded. The Indians were following the example of the colonies—uniting to further their common interests. Then Tecumseh tipped his hand, saying he intended to travel to Washington to settle his differences with the president when he returned.

While he was away, Tecumseh expected many visitors to his village. He hoped Harrison would prevent whites from settling on the disputed lands to avoid trouble.

Harrison had no intention of keeping white settlers off the Indian lands. Instead, he prepared for war. He asked the secretary of war to send him the 4th Regiment from Pittsburg. Harrison also requested permission to attack the Indians at Prophetstown should he learn their intentions were hostile. Then, uncharacteristically, he acknowledged that the Native Americans had often been mistreated. “I wish I could say the Indians were treated with justice and propriety on all occasions,” he told the Secretary, “but it is often otherwise. They are often abused and mistreated. It is very rare that they obtain any satisfaction for the most unprovoked wrongs.”

Harrison wrote the secretary again on July 10, 1811. “Tecumseh has taken for his model the celebrated Pontiac, and I am persuaded he will bear a favorable comparison in every respect.”

In August 1811, Tecumseh headed south. He spent nearly six months on a swing through Tennessee, Alabama, Georgia, Florida, and the Carolinas. The Choctaws wanted nothing to do with Tecumseh and escorted his party out of their lands. The Cherokee had no interest. Thirty warriors and one chief from the Lower Creeks accompanied him to Prophetstown to learn more about the prophet’s religion.

The Battle of Tippecanoe

The destruction of Prophetstown seemed out of proportion to the spark that caused it. Some horses were stolen near the prophet’s village, and the Indians fired a few shots at the whites as they tried to retrieve them. William Henry Harrison took revenge on the entire village and marched his army toward Prophetstown.

On October 27, he sent a delegation of Delaware chiefs to sound Tenskwatawa out, but Tenskwatawa would not listen. Harrison sent a delegation of Miami on October 29. They did not return.

The army advanced to within ten miles of Prophetstown on November 5, then moved another five miles the next day. Harrison camped his army within a mile of the village the day after.

Tenskwatawa sent three emissaries to ask why the army marched on his town. After all, his people behaved peacefully and minded their own business on their land. Why should the whites send an army against them? Harrison agreed to suspend hostilities and meet with Tenskwatawa the following day.

The army camped by a creek three-quarters of a mile outside of Prophetstown. One hundred and thirty men stood guard, while another eight hundred lay on their arms.

The prophet’s forces launched their attack at about 4 a.m. The soldiers grabbed their guns and extinguished their campfires. Then, they charged the native lines at daybreak, pushing them back into the swamps.

The prophet stood on a small hill overlooking the battlefield, chanting a war song. He worked his magic before going into battle and assured his warriors the Long Knives’ bullets would bounce off their bodies. They would have plenty of light to find their enemy while the Americans floundered hopelessly in the dark.

It didn’t happen.

The American bullets chopped down rush after rush of the native warriors. The cold steel of the soldier’s bayonets sliced them apart.

The warriors abandoned the prophet’s town and scattered to the wind. “You are a liar,” screamed a Winnebago warrior, waving his tomahawk at Tenskwatawa. “You told us the white people were dead or crazy when they were all in their senses and fought like the devil.”

The prophet chants on the hill as the Battle of Tippecanoe rages below him

Indian agent John Johnston reported that the prophet’s forces suffered 28 killed, and many more wounded. He estimated the prophet had 350 warriors engaged in the battle, most of them—Kickapoo and Winnebago, with a few Shawnees.

He believed the Native Americans would solve the government’s problem and kill Tecumseh and Tenskwatawa for their part in the affair. If they did, he assured the tribes the government would not interfere. “Whatever punishment they might think proper to inflict on them,” said Johnston, “would be agreeable to the president of the U. States.”

Tenskwatawa attributed the defeat to a mistake in mixing his concoction. Other sources said he was unaware his wife was menstruating. That interfered with his spell. A few of Tenskwatawa’s followers stuck with him after the battle, but most dismissed him as a fraud.

For Tecumseh, the battle proved a new beginning. He visited William Henry Harrison in Vincennes and asked to meet with President James Madison in Washington. Then, just as quickly, Tecumseh changed his mind when Harrison told him only a few of his braves could accompany him.

Tecumseh joins the British

When the War of 1812 began, Tecumseh traveled to Malden, joining forces with Major General Sir Isaac Brock.

The British erected defensive works at Sandwich, opposite Fort Detroit, on August 14 and set up a battery comprising two eighteen-pounders and an eight-inch howitzer. The Americans watched as the British fortified their position but did nothing to stop them.

The next day, Colonel McDonald and Captain Glegg crossed the river to Detroit under a flag of truce to deliver a message from General Brock ordering the garrison to surrender.

After that, the British and Native Americans played an elaborate game of psych with the Americans. Brock ordered the Canadian militia to wear the uniform of the 41st Regiment to make it seem like he had a more experienced force. Then, when the army camped for the night, he had the men light individual fires, so it appeared he had a more significant force.

Tecumseh completed the deception, marching his warriors around the fort three times. To General Hull, who was already worried about the Native Americans, it seemed like there must be savages lurking behind every tree.

He remembered Brock’s surrender demand: “It is far from my inclination to join in a war of extermination. You must be aware that the numerous body of Indians who have attached themselves to my troops will be beyond my control the moment the contest commences.”

Two American twenty-four pounders loaded with grapeshot were set up and ready to sweep the field. “Every man expected a proud day for his country,” wrote the New York Evening Post. Every man stood ready for battle. Instead, General Hull ordered the guns not to fire and the men to stack their weapons. Then he raised a white flag over the wall and surrendered without firing a shot.

The next day, Brock wrote his superiors: “2500 troops have this day surrendered prisoners of war. Twenty-five pieces of ordnance have been taken without the sacrifice of British blood. I had not more than 600 troops, including militia, and about 600 Indians.” He was “astonished” by his good fortune.

William Hull defended his actions, saying he only had eight hundred effective troops to fight the British assault. That left the camp’s women, children, and elderly vulnerable to attack. His only option was to surrender. His troops were outnumbered, and the fort was short on powder and provisions.

What really preyed on his mind were the Native Americans. “The bands of savages which had then joined the British force were numerous beyond any former example. Their numbers have since increased.”

The fall of Detroit gave the Native forces free rein over the Michigan Territory. Tribes that were once neutral or on the cusp of siding with the British took advantage of the situation, joined the British, or sent raiding parties to terrorize the scattered settlements.

General William Hull worried about the Indians, surrendered Fort Detroit without a fight

The siege of Fort Meigs

The siege of Fort Meigs was the closest Tecumseh came to realizing his dream of an Indian homeland. The stakes were enormous for the Shawnee chieftain. If the campaign proved successful, General Procter hinted he would give the Native Americans the Michigan Territory as a reward for their services. In addition, he promised to deliver William Henry Harrison to be disposed of at Tecumseh’s “pleasure.”

Fort Mackinac, Fort Dearborn, and then Fort Detroit fell in quick succession.

William Henry Harrison assumed control of the Army of the Northwest shortly after Hull’s surrender of Detroit. In February 1813, he moved his army to the Maumee River Rapids and constructed Fort Meigs.

It was a large, octagonal structure, with “eight blockhouses, picketed with timber, and surrounded by ditches,” on a bluff overlooking the Maumee River Rapids.

General Procter began assembling his forces at Sandwich on April 7. Tecumseh and the Prophet arrived at the end of the month with about 600 warriors.

By April 28, the British and Native Americans were within a few miles of the fort. Harrison waited inside Fort Meigs, hoping General Green Clay and his Kentuckians would arrive in time.

The British set up three batteries on a high bluff opposite the fort. Early the following day, they opened fire. The British kept the cannonading up for five days, but it had little effect. The native forces crept up to the stockade nightly, firing shots and harassing the troops as they went outside to collect water and firewood.

On May 5, General Procter sent Major Chambers to demand the post surrender at once “to spare the effusion of blood.” Chambers explained that the British had a larger party of Native Americans with them than had ever been assembled. Controlling them after a battle could prove problematic. Harrison replied that the post would not be surrendered “upon any terms.”

That same day, Harrison sent Captain Hamilton with orders for General Clay, who had just arrived outside the fort. He was to land 800 men about a mile above the fort and lead them to the British batteries.

The Kentuckians formed three lines spread roughly a quarter of a mile apart. The first line was to attack and carry the batteries, then spike the cannons. The second line supported the first, and the third was held in reserve. They were supposed to hop in their boats and cross over to Fort Meigs when they finished. Harrison planned a Sallie outside the fort to cover their landing and entrance into it.

The first line quickly carried the batteries, but the second line fell behind and could not support them. The native warriors drew the third line into the woods and slaughtered them.

When the remaining troops arrived at their boats, they found the ground occupied by the British, who advanced on them with fixed bayonets. The majority surrendered to the British, hoping to save themselves from the Native forces.

Siege of Fort Meigs

“The British formed a circle around them in order to protect them against the vengeance of the savages,” said one survivor. The British did everything possible to protect the American soldiers, but several prisoners were killed. “The British appeared to possess little or no control over them,” he added. In addition, the Native Americans “killed two British soldiers for attempting to prevent them from murdering our men after the surrender.”

Six hundred fifty Kentuckians were killed or taken prisoner in the attack—150 made it into the fort. The Virginia Argus reported that 77 Americans died during the siege, and 196 were wounded.

The British called off the siege on May 9 and returned to their fortress at Malden. After the siege, Harrison turned command of the fort over to General Green Clay.

Harrison couldn’t help thinking things could have gone differently. If Colonel Dudley had followed orders and retreated as soon as his men spiked the cannons, he could have easily beaten the British. “The Indians would have abandoned the British that night,” Harrison wrote Kentucky Governor Isaac Shelby, “if they had not succeeded against Colonel Dudley.” Instead, he was “deprived of their services at the most critical moment” by sending men to assist Dudley.

A second try at Fort Meigs

The second siege of Fort Meigs occurred in July. Tecumseh staged a mock battle outside the fort to draw the garrison out.

It started with a gun battle just before nightfall on July 26. War cries broke out, and the Native Americans were seen attacking a small force.

Many men inside the fort believed it was General Harrison’s relief column, so they seized their guns and prepared to attack.

General Clay couldn’t explain the attack but assured his men it wasn’t a relief column. Captain McCune had scouted the area that morning. He assured him that no American troops were nearby. Clay refused to let anyone leave the fort.

The British and Native Americans gave up the siege a few days later and rode away.

Tecumseh grew tired of Procter’s empty promises and lack of leadership. He intended to abandon the British after the second siege of Fort Meigs and return home. The British “treat us like  dogs of snipe hunters,” he told his followers. “We are always sent ahead to start the game. It is better we should return to our country and let the Americans come on and fight the British.”

Tecumseh’s followers talked him into staying—against his better judgment.

The defense of Fort Stephenson

While Tecumseh didn’t take part in the attack on Fort Stephenson, the threat of his Native American alliance was ever-present. When the siege of Fort Meigs ended, Harrison figured the enemy would attempt to take Fort Stephenson, so rather than risk a fight, he ordered Major George Croghan, the 21-year-old commander, to burn the fort and move his command to headquarters at Lower Seneca.

Croghan disobeyed the order, saying he was “capable and willing to defend the post.” He later explained that the decision was made in a council with his officers. They thought retreating in daylight, before the enemy’s entire force, would be more dangerous than remaining in the fort and fighting it out.

"Old Betsy" thunders shot and balls at the Battle of Fort Stephenson

Croghan dug a seven by nine-foot trench around the fort. He hauled logs to the top of the walls, ready to drop on the attackers, and nailed bayonets to the ramparts to prevent the walls from being scaled.

About noon on August 1, the Native Americans surrounded the fort. They formed at the edge of the clearing as if to make a charge, but a shot from “Old Betsy,” the fort’s antique six-pounder, scared them off.

Overnight, the British landed more artillery and set up a battery of five cannons on a tree-covered hill, roughly 250 yards from the fort.

The British gunboats opened fire at about 4:00 p.m. At the same time, the regulars disembarked a mile below the fort and set up a howitzer. Croghan had his men move “Old Betsy” from porthole to porthole—firing an occasional shot to make the fort’s defenses appear stronger than they were.

After positioning his troops, Procter sent Colonel Elliott and Major Chambers to demand the fort’s surrender. Elliott implied that the “whole of the garrison would likely be massacred” if they did not surrender because it would be impossible to control the Native Americans.

Ensign Edmund Shipp replied that Major Croghan, his officers, and men were determined to “defend the garrison, or be buried in it.”

A short time later, the British opened fire from the gunboats and a five-inch howitzer on the shore. The fire kept up all night. The following day, they opened with five six-pounders from the shore.

Major Croghan and Captain James Hunter noticed the bulk of the fire was concentrated against the fort’s northwest angle and decided the enemy intended to breach the walls there. The garrison immediately strengthened that section of the fort with bags of flour and sand.

Soon after that, 500 regulars closed on the fort. They made two feints on the south wall. The column that marched on the northwest angle became completely enveloped in smoke. The defenders could not see them until they were within 18 to 20 paces of the fort.

Just as the British leaped into the ditch, “a masked porthole was suddenly opened. A six-pounder with a half charge of leaden slugs poured destruction upon them and killed or wounded nearly every man who had entered the ditch.” The British turned tail and fled into the woods.

Croghan reported his losses as one dead and seven injured. His best guess was 150 to 200 casualties for the British and Native Americans. They found fifty dead or wounded soldiers lying in the ditch alone.

Tecumseh’s last stand

After the British defeat on Lake Erie, General Procter burned Forts Malden and Detroit and retreated to Canada. But first, there would be a final battle on the Thames to satisfy Tecumseh that the British were not abandoning their Native American allies.

William Henry Harrison followed close on their trail with 3500 regulars and militia, nearly double the British force of 600 regulars, Canadians, and 1,000 Native Americans.

Procter was eager to make his escape. He passed several locations the native forces believed would give them the advantage in a fight. Then, Tecumseh sensed another sellout by the British and demanded that the army make a stand.

He admonished Procter. “We must compare our father’s conduct to a fat dog that carries his tail on its back but, when affrighted drops it between its legs and runs off.”

Unsure that he could convince Procter to fight, Tecumseh changed tactics. “You have got the arms and ammunition which our Great Father sent for his red children. If you have an idea of going away, give them to us, and you may go and welcome. Our lives are in the hands of the Great Spirit. We are determined to defend our lands, and if it be His will, we wish to leave our bones upon them.”

Fighting erupted near Moraviantown early on October 5, as the British ate breakfast. They formed two lines—the British in the woods and Tecumseh’s forces in the swamps.

Procter fled the field minutes after the battle started, heading east to Moraviantown and then through the forest to Burlington.

“The American backwoodsmen ride better in the woods than any other people,” wrote William Henry Harrison. “A musket or a rifle is no impediment to them.” He told the Secretary of War the British regulars surrendered within a minute of the contest’s start.

The Native Americans fought for nearly an hour. Colonel Richard Johnson, the leader of the Kentucky cavalry, took several bullets in the first fire. “We struck the Indian lines obliquely,” said Colonel James Davidson. “The Indians poured in a heavy fire upon us, killing ten or fifteen of our men and several horses.”

Death of Tecumseh at the Battle of Thames

Tecumseh died fighting in the swamps. As word of his death spread along the lines, the Native Americans slipped away, ending the battle. How many died in the action is uncertain—the militia counted 33 dead warriors on the field—but did not know how many they carried away.

The battle was not particularly bloody. The Americans suffered 15 killed and 30 wounded; the British, 18 killed and 26 wounded.

 Before you go ...

If you’ve ever caught yourself saying, “I remember that,” you’re in the right place.

I dig up stories about Old West lawmen, outlaws, gunfighters, robberies, murders, forgotten towns, and all the strange, fascinating pieces of history that somehow slipped through the cracks. No clickbait. No fluff. Just authentic stories and actual history.

If you enjoy what you read and would like to help keep the lights on, consider buying me a Big Gulp.

Every little bit helps pay for books, newspaper archives, research trips, and the countless hours spent tracking down stories most people forgot decades ago.

Buy Me a Big Gulp / NickVulich.com

If the Old West is your thing, you may enjoy these books...

Shot All To Hell

Shot All To Pieces


No comments:

Post a Comment