| Abraham Lincoln |
The election of 1860 is like no other in the history of
the American Republic. There is talk of
civil war if Lincoln’s Black Republicans take the election. Many newspapers predict an “irresistible conflict.” One
that will determine once and for all if
the country is to be “free labor” or “slave labor.”
For a while, the
South strutted after the Supreme Court decision handed down with Dred Scott.
The court ruled that slaves were property. “Protected by all the Constitutional
guarantees of property and went where the
Constitution went; neither a territorial legislature nor Congress could exclude slavery from a territory
because they could not exclude the Constitution therefrom.”
To many Southerners
and President Buchanan, it seemed as if the case was closed. Slavery was the law of the land. Nothing could stop it.
Not so for Abraham
Lincoln.
During the
Lincoln-Douglas debates in 1858, Abraham Lincoln goaded Stephen Douglas until
he took the bait and acknowledged the decision meant nothing more than that black people, not being citizens, could not sue
in court. Nowhere in the case did it mention the territories. So, the decision
did not impact slavery in the territories.
“No matter what the
decision of the Supreme Court may be on that abstract question,” Douglas told
the crowd. “Still, the right of the people to make a slave territory or a free Territory is perfect and complete under the
Nebraska bill.” And then, as if to make his point, Douglas added, “I hope Mr.
Lincoln deems my answer satisfactory on that point.”
Douglas’s decision
that day became known as the Freeport Doctrine (named after the Illinois town
that hosted the debate). It helped Douglas win the Senatorial election. But it
created a rift in the Democratic Party that lost him the 1860 Presidential
election.
Broaching the
subject was a significant risk for Lincoln,
but paid big dividends. John Nicolay and John Hay later said Lincoln told them,
“If Douglas answers, he can never be President.”
