Saturday, October 3, 2026

Lemp Brewery In St. Louis: Makers Of Falstaff Beer

 

Lemp Brewery in St. Louis, Missouri
(color drawing after a photo in the St. Louis Star & Times. March 14, 1914)

The Lemps knew how to get their name in front of people. They put it on bottles, advertisements, and the side of a smokestack. By the 1870s, they ran the largest brewery in St. Louis.

 

Before all that, there was a grocery store.

 

Johann Adam Lemp came to St. Louis in 1838. He’d learned to brew in Germany and started making beer while running his store. The lager found customers. Enough of them that groceries stopped being the principal business.

 

The family claimed 1840 as the brewery’s founding year. Historians haven’t quite settled that, but records show brewing operations by 1841. Adam called it the Western Brewery and set up near the riverfront.

 

He had beer to make and a problem to solve.

 

Lager needed to stay cold while it aged. St. Louis got hot, and a brewer couldn’t leave barrels sitting through a Missouri summer and expect everything to turn out fine.

 

Adam used caves.


The limestone caverns beneath the city stayed cool. Ice cut from the Mississippi helped keep the storage cold. Workers had to cut it, haul it, and put it away. Before refrigeration machinery, that was part of getting a glass of lager to the customer.

William J. Lemp, Sr. (St. Louis Post-Dispatch. February 13, 1904)


The caves gave Adam room to build the business. His son, William, built a brewery above them.

 

Adam died in 1862. William took over and opened the larger plant near Cherokee Street in 1864. He kept adding to it until the brewery covered five city blocks.

 

It had towers, arched windows, and brickwork worth looking at. The buildings were factories, but the Lemps spent money on how they looked. They had a business people could see from the street and a name they wanted people to remember.

 

Anheuser-Busch was growing in the same city. For a time, Lemp was bigger.

 

William bought machinery that helped him make more beer and send it farther. Refrigeration took some of the burden off the caves and river ice. Bottling and pasteurization helped beer travel without going bad.

 

Then there was the railroad.

 

The family operated the Western Cable Railway Company and shipped beer under refrigeration. William wasn’t waiting for people to come to St. Louis for a drink. He was getting Lemp beer into other cities, then other countries.

 

By the 1890s, it was going overseas.

 

The bottles carried several names. Standard. Extra Pale. Culmbacher. Tally. Tip Top. The company sold different beers under different labels, giving a customer more to ask for than just a Lemp.


William J. Lemp, Jr. (St. Louis Republic. Juy 12, 1908)


Falstaff was the name that stuck.

 

It came from Shakespeare’s Sir John Falstaff, who liked food, drink, and getting his own way. The brewery introduced the brand in the 1890s. It became valuable enough that somebody wanted it even after the Lemps were through.

 

For years, though, they had little reason to think they’d be through.

 

The brewery was large. The beer traveled. William had a mansion nearby and the money to make it a showplace. He filled the house with expensive finishes, adding conveniences most families didn’t have.

 

His son Frederick was expected to carry the business forward, but he died of heart failure in 1901. William took the loss hard. Then his close friend, Frederick Pabst, another man who’d made a fortune in beer, died in January 1904. The following month, William died by suicide at the family mansion.

 

The brewery passed to William Jr., known as Billy. His troubles went into the newspapers.

 

His marriage to Lillian Handlan ended in a bitter divorce. The family’s money and name made the fight news. People who’d never been inside the mansion could read about what was going wrong there.

 

Outside the house, another fight was closing in.

 

The temperance movement wanted alcohol outlawed. Brewers could expand their plants, improve their equipment, and buy more advertising. They couldn’t sell ordinary beer if the government made it illegal.

 

Lemp tried Cerva.

 

It was a nonalcoholic malt beverage, something the company could make as restrictions threatened the beer trade. Unfortunately, Cerva didn’t earn enough to save it.

 

The brewery closed on May 3, 1919. Nationwide constitutional Prohibition took effect the following January. Lemp was already out.

 

Billy sold the Falstaff name and logo to Joseph Griesedieck in 1920. International Shoe Company bought the brewery property in 1922. The buildings had another use, and Falstaff had another owner.

 

The family’s bad luck continued.

 

Billy’s sister Elsa died by suicide in 1920. Billy died by suicide at the mansion in December 1922, just months after the brewery’s sale.

 

Their brother, Charles, stayed on for decades. In 1949, he also died by suicide at the mansion. Four members of the family had died that way in forty-five years.

 

People eventually called it a curse. The mansion became a restaurant and inn, and the ghost stories became part of what brought people through the door.

 

The brewery had brought people there for a different reason. They wanted beer. The Lemps made it, bottled it, and shipped it far beyond St. Louis. For decades, that was what the family name meant.

 

Anheuser-Busch survived Prohibition. The Lemp family brewery didn’t. But Falstaff returned under new ownership, and people kept ordering it.

 

The name on the bottle outlasted the business that put it there.

 

Before you go...

If you’ve ever stayed up way too late watching a true crime documentary, gone down a rabbit hole reading about an unsolved murder, or found yourself saying, “How have I never heard this case before?”—you’re in the right place.

I dig into murders, disappearances, serial killers, cold cases, small-town mysteries, forgotten crimes, and the strange, unsettling stories that time almost erased. No sensationalized headlines. No made-up drama. Just well-researched stories built from newspaper archives, court records, police reports, and historical documents.

If you enjoy what you read and would like to help keep the lights on, consider buying me a Big Gulp.

Every little bit helps pay for old newspapers, research materials, public records, travel, and the countless hours spent piecing together stories that deserve to be remembered.

Buy Me a Big Gulp / NickVulich.com

If true crime is your thing, you might also enjoy these books...

Gruesome Iowa

Gruesome Illinois

Gruesome California

Gruesome Serial Killers

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment